Belgian Study: Tesla FSD System Often Misreads Speed Limits and Overtakes Illegally
By Chris Kirkham and Marie Mannes
Findings and Reactions to Tesla FSD Performance in Belgium
Overview of the Belgian Study
Sept 24 (Reuters) - Tesla’s FSD automated-driving system frequently exceeded speed limits and attempted to overtake cyclists on streets where it's prohibited, a road-safety advocacy group said, citing tests it conducted in Belgium.
The Belgian group Johanna.be - which advocates for pedestrian and cyclist safety - tested Tesla’s system over 3 days in July, covering about 400 km (249 miles). It found that FSD often exceeded speed limits in 20 km/h and 30 km/h zones, and incorrectly displayed higher speed limits to drivers, potentially misleading them about how fast the vehicle should travel.
Regulatory Approvals and Concerns
Tesla’s FSD driver-assistance feature can perform most driving tasks but requires drivers to pay strict attention. Dutch regulator RDW approved the system in April, with Belgium and a handful of other countries following suit. An EU-wide vote could happen on October 6.
Several EU countries, including Sweden, have expressed concerns about FSD exceeding speed limits, while countries that approved it say drivers remain responsible for complying with traffic laws.
Tesla did not respond to Reuters requests for comment.
RDW said it had received the report and would consider it as part of its applicable monitoring and surveillance processes, adding that conclusions about vehicle systems require "a thorough evaluation of all relevant information and context".
Tesla released a study earlier this month saying that FSD-enabled Teslas do not speed excessively and drive at speeds matching surrounding traffic.
'A Learning System': Official Responses
Flemish Government Perspective
'A LEARNING SYSTEM'
Xavier Lesenne, spokesperson for the Flemish government’s transportation ministry, which approved FSD in Belgium earlier this year, said it is "a learning system that continuously processes new and additional information" and adapts over time. Lesenne said the driver "remains 100% responsible" and must be ready to intervene "should the system make an error or fail to correctly apply a traffic rule".
Lesenne said data from Tesla shows the technology "holds significant potential for accident prevention today".
Test Results: Speed Limit Compliance
Johanna.be found that FSD exceeded the limit in the majority of the tested 30 km/h road segments around Brussels, averaging 44 km/h.
Even though the vehicle's screen showed the system recognised 30 km/h speed-limit signs on the roadside, it often displayed an incorrect speed limit of 50 km/h.
"It is akin to a passenger constantly reassuring the driver that the speed limit is 50 km/h in nearly every 30-zone through which they pass," the report said.
Overtaking Cyclists and Road Rule Compliance
Videos collected by the group show the FSD-enabled Tesla attempting to overtake cyclists on streets where doing so is not allowed.
The European Transport Safety Council has previously raised concerns about whether FSD can comply with differing road rules across Europe.
Positive Aspects and Remaining Concerns
The Johanna.be report also noted positive aspects of the system, saying it "behaved cautiously and courteously around pedestrians and cyclists, often yielding proactively."
But those benefits "do not offset the documented failures to comply with speed limits and cycle-street regulations."
Calls for Reassessment
The NGO said it sent the report to the Flemish ministry and RDW, urging both to reassess the approvals.
(Reporting by Chris Kirkham in Los Angeles, Marie Mannes in Stockholm; Editing by Alexandra Hudson and Emelia Sithole-Matarise)
