Ex-PNG Footballer Calls FIFA's Funding System Flawed for Smaller Nations
FIFA Funding Challenges for Smaller Football Federations
By Nick Mulvenney
Silence Among Oceania Federations Amid FIFA Turmoil
SYDNEY, Aug 11 (Reuters) - Former Papua New Guinea international Alex Davani says some of the smaller football federations have kept quiet during FIFA's civil war because they fear losing the funding that is vital to their operations.
Davani, a former deputy general secretary of Football Australia, believes global soccer's development funding system is flawed and hopes the discussions prompted by Gianni Infantino's abandoned FIFA Forward Enterprise proposal might create the environment for reform.
The 11-member Oceania federation were scheduled to meet on Wednesday to discuss the row that has split world football asunder and Davani thinks they are in a tough spot.
FIFA Funding as a Lifeline
"I don't think the sort of institutional silence or the quiet coming out of the region is complicity or apathy or anything like that," the lawyer and sports administrator told Reuters in an interview from Brisbane.
"I actually think it's almost a predictable response in an environment where the FIFA ... development funding is often at times the entire operational budget for a member association from Oceania. So in that context, I think they've been placed in a tricky position.
"On the one hand, you have some of the big confederations coming out being very vocal about the proposal. And on the other hand, you have a situation where, not right or wrong, and maybe not intentionally, I think it's just a situation where speaking or forming a view may perhaps risk that funding.
"You don't want to put that at risk because it's your livelihood."
Systemic Flaws in FIFA's Funding Model
The flaw in the system, Davani believes, is that FIFA's funding is discretionary, not an entitlement.
Entitlement vs. Discretionary Funding
"Whilst the FIFA statutes quite frequently talk about development funding and development programs, nowhere in there is it enshrined the sort of principle that development money is an entitlement versus discretionary money," he said.
"We all believe that the World Cup and the Women's World Cup, they belong to us (and) the development funding derives from those major assets. So I do think that if we have the sense of belonging to it, member associations can certainly decide where it should go."
Impact of FIFA Funding on Oceania
National Football Centres and Infrastructure
NATIONAL FOOTBALL CENTRES
Davani said that smaller federations, like most of those in Oceania, have done well out of Infantino's decade in charge of FIFA with funding increasing from $2 million-$3 million over a four-year cycle to $8 million in the last round.
Infantino inaugurated a new national football centre in PNG funded by FIFA Forward money in 2023, and another has opened in the Solomon Islands. Vanuatu has a new stadium.
Leadership and Regional Needs
While the prospect of the $40 million that Infantino promised if the 211 full member associations had opted for his controversial plan would have been tempting, Davani believes that is missing the point about what kind of FIFA president Oceania needs.
"For a region like Oceania, we need our leaders to have a real understanding of some of the things that impact the growth and development of professional football," he said.
Unique Challenges for Oceania
"It's really expensive to move around the islands, for example, climate change means we're losing islands and places to play, and the advancement of indigenous peoples' rights are important to the region.
"I think that's the standard of leader that Oceania has every right to expect."
Untapped Football Talent in Oceania
Citing Tim Cahill, who played for Samoa before switching to Australia, and French World Cup winner Christian Karembeu, who was born in New Caledonia, Davani said there was plenty of talent in Oceania if it could be developed properly.
"I think the disappointing thing for me about this entire (FIFA schism) is we stop talking about football, especially in a region where it needs to be played more often," he said.
"I don't think talent has been the issue. I think it's been the systems around that talent, which is why I'm really keen for us to get back to the football discussion."
(Reporting by Nick Mulvenney, editing by Peter Rutherford)