Telegram says Apple suspension followed content norms violation by one user
By Rishabh Jaiswal
Apple's Brief Suspension of Telegram and Its Aftermath
Aug 3 (Reuters) - Telegram was briefly removed from Apple's App Store globally after the iPhone maker reported one user had shared "child sexual abuse material," the messaging app said on Tuesday.
Background: Previous Incidents and Safeguards
The incident follows a similar suspension in 2018, when Apple temporarily pulled Telegram for material the app's founder Pavel Durov called "inappropriate content" at the time, only to be restored after Telegram beefed up safeguards.
Apple's Statement and Telegram's Response
Apple's Position on the Suspension
An Apple spokesperson confirmed the recent brief removal, saying its review found content that violated guidelines prohibiting child sexual abuse material.
"The app was subsequently restored after the developer promptly removed the content and banned the user who posted it,” the spokesperson added.
The app was removed and restored on the same day, after Telegram took action.
Telegram's Zero-Tolerance Policy
Telegram, which has more than a billion monthly active users, says it has a zero-tolerance policy for material on child sexual abuse, blocking nearly 338,000 groups and channels over such items this year.
"I'm sure this stance will be applied equally to all other apps in the store, in the future, right? Apple," Telegram posted on X in response to a user who shared the Apple statement.
Industry and Regulatory Reactions
Criticism from Industry Leaders
Tim Sweeney, the CEO of Fornite-maker Epic Games, which has been embroiled in legal challenges with Apple for years, questioned the U.S. tech giant's decision.
"Apple has stated they removed the app from availability to a billion users because a Telegram user posted something horrible and illegal," Sweeney wrote on X.
"They did not elaborate on how, if that is the standard for app removal, any communications app could operate at scale, including iMessage."
Apple's Silence on Further Clarification
An Apple spokesperson did not respond to a request for further comment on the guideline violation.
Ongoing Regulatory Scrutiny
Investigations into Telegram's Content Moderation
Telegram has drawn regulatory scrutiny for its handling of child sexual abuse material and other illegal content as recently as April, when Britain's Ofcom launched an investigation into evidence suggesting sharing of child sex abuse material.
Telegram's Defense and Past Actions
Telegram has "categorically" denied the communications regulator's accusations, adding that since 2018 it had "virtually eliminated" the public spread of child sexual abuse material through detection algorithms.
Penalties and Compliance Efforts
Telegram was also fined in February by Australia's online safety regulator for delaying answers to queries on measures taken to rein in material on child abuse and violent extremist behaviour.
(Reporting by Rishabh Jaiswal in Bengaluru and Mrinmay Dey in Mexico City; Editing by Christopher Cushing, Edwina Gibbs and Clarence Fernandez)
