International Criminal Court members dismiss prosecutor Khan over sexual misconduct allegation
ICC Prosecutor Karim Khan Dismissed Amid Misconduct Allegations
By Stephanie van den Berg
July 24 (Reuters) - Member states of the International Criminal Court voted to dismiss prosecutor Karim Khan for serious misconduct, the ICC said on Friday.
Allegations and Dismissal Process
Diplomats running the executive bureau of the court's governing body said last month the British barrister had an inappropriate sexual relationship with a junior ICC lawyer and should be fired, documents seen by Reuters showed. On Friday, a large majority of the ICC's 125 member states voted to follow that recommendation.
Official Statement on Dismissal
"The assembly decided by a majority of 82 states parties that the elected official, prosecutor, Karim Khan, committed serious misconduct and a serious breach of duty ... and to remove ... Karim Khan from office," the president of the court's governing body, Paivi Kaukoranta, said.
Khan's Response
Khan, 56, denies any wrongdoing.
"Mr. Khan will challenge the lawfulness and fairness of the decision through all available legal mechanisms," his lawyer, Tayab Ali, said after the vote.
Next Steps for the ICC
Khan's dismissal immediately triggers the election process for a new ICC prosecutor who is not expected to be voted in before next year.
"Members of the court acted swiftly and decisively to remove an embattled and discredited official so that the court can move forward with its important work in all the situations on its docket,” said Leila Sadat, professor of international criminal law at Washington University.
International and U.S. Reactions
U.S. Pushback Against the ICC
DISMISSAL FOLLOWS RENEWED U.S. PUSHBACK
Khan's dismissal follows an announcement by the United States that it will launch a renewed diplomatic campaign to dismantle the ICC, which it says is a threat to its sovereignty.
During a visit to the Philippines on Thursday, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio said there were "lunatics and crazies involved in the ICC" and there was no way any U.S. political or military officials would ever go on trial at the court, reiterating previous criticism.
State Department spokesperson Tommy Pigott welcomed Khan's removal but said, "he is only one small cog in this irredeemably corrupt institution. Today's outcome will have no impact on the United States' plans to dismantle the ICC."
Sanctions and ICC Credibility
The U.S., which is not a member, has imposed sanctions on 11 ICC judges and prosecutors, including Khan, citing the ICC's arrest warrants against Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former defence minister Yoav Gallant, and a past probe into U.S. troops in Afghanistan.
While removing Khan helps the ICC's credibility by showing it has accountability for its own leadership, the court has more hurdles to overcome, said Kyra Wigard, assistant professor of law at Utrecht University.
"The bigger challenge going forward is whether the court can restore confidence internally and externally while maintaining the perception of independence amid intense geopolitical pressure," she said.
Details of the Allegations
Public Accusations
Khan's accuser spoke publicly for the first time last week in an interview with CNN in which she repeated her allegations that the prosecutor had a non-consensual sexual relationship with her.
Khan's Legal Defense
Lawyers for Khan told Reuters he denied "any sexual relationship of any kind" with the junior lawyer.
Impact on ICC Operations
Ongoing Warrants
Any active ICC warrants will remain in place because only ICC judges have the authority to withdraw warrants.
(Reporting by Stephanie van den Berg in The Hague; Editing by Alison Williams and Rod Nickel)
