David Thomson discussing employee fraud risks in SMEs - Global Banking & Finance Review
David Thomson, CEO of Close Brothers Invoice Finance, highlights the alarming rise of fraudulent references in SMEs, emphasizing the risks to business integrity and financial health.
Top Stories

ONE IN FIVE SMES DUPED BY JOB SEEKERS

Published by Gbaf News

Posted on September 16, 2014

2 min read
Add as preferred source on Google

Fraudulent References Affecting UK SMEs

As many as one in five small and medium sized firms across the UK have received a fraudulent reference for a potential job candidate, a survey has revealed.

Of that number, more than half (56%) say that it has happened between one and five times in the last five years alone, while one in 10 state that they have received more than 10 dishonest job references in that time period.

Key Survey Findings on Job References

The figures, which are drawn from the Close Brothers Business Barometer, a poll of SME owners and senior management across the UK, also suggest that the most commonly received false references are for mid-level positions (51%), followed by entry or low level positions (45%).

David Thomson

David Thomson

CEO of Close Brothers Invoice Finance, David Thomson said: “The scale of reference falsification is quite surprising but also alarming. Employee fraud could pose a significant threat to a small business both in terms of its image, reputational damage and ultimately financial wellbeing.

Methods and Motivations Behind Fake References

“An artificial reference could be used to exaggerate experience, cover up breaks in employment, or to conceal an otherwise poor recommendation from a former employer. It’s not difficult to imagine how hiring someone who has in some way deceived you about their work history could potentially cause serious issues down the line.”

Fictional Reference Websites Pose New Risks

The Close Brothers Business Barometer also found that more than half (56%) of employers are unaware of the existence of websites that offer fictional references in return for a fee.

Importance of Managing Employee Fraud Risk

“Managing the risk of employee fraud should be high on the list of priorities for all businesses and it merits attention in a firm’s overall risk management strategy,” added Mr Thomson.

“The important thing is to be aware that this type of dishonesty exists so that you can take the necessary steps to protect your business.”

Key Takeaways

  • Around 20% of UK SMEs have received at least one fraudulent job reference over the past five years.
  • Over half of those affected report between one and five such incidents; 10% report more than ten.
  • Mid-level positions are the most commonly falsified references (51%), followed by entry-level roles (45%).
  • 56% of employers are unaware of websites that sell fictional job references.
  • Close Brothers warns that reference falsification poses reputational, operational and financial risks to SMEs.

References

Frequently Asked Questions

How common is job reference fraud among UK SMEs?
About one in five SMEs say they have received a fraudulent reference in the past five years.
What levels of positions are most targeted?
Mid‑level positions are most frequently affected (51%), followed by entry‑level roles (45%).
How many fraudulent references do SMEs typically experience?
Over half report between one and five incidents, while around 10% report more than ten over five years.
Are businesses aware of websites offering fake references?
No — 56% of employers are unaware that paid sites offering fictional references exist.
Why is reference fraud a concern for SMEs?
It can harm reputation, financial health and operational integrity if candidates have falsified their experience.

Tags

Related Articles

More from Top Stories

Explore more articles in the Top Stories category