Realtek sues semiconductor rival MediaTek over patent ‘bounty’ agreement

Realtek sues semiconductor rival MediaTek over patent ‘bounty’ agreement

By Blake Brittain

(Reuters) -Realtek Semiconductor Corp sued rival Taiwanese chipmaker MediaTek Inc in Northern California federal court on Tuesday, claiming MediaTek paid a company that sues over patents a “secret litigation bounty” to file meritless lawsuits in the United States to disrupt its business.

The lawsuit accuses MediaTek of conspiring with IPValue Management Inc in an effort to drive Realtek out of the market and monopolize the industry for chips used in smart televisions and set-top boxes.

MediaTek owns nearly 60% of the global market share for television chips, the lawsuit said.

Realtek said in a statement that it filed the lawsuit to “protect free and fair competition in the industry” and “prevent further harm to the public.”

MediaTek declined comment, citing the ongoing litigation.

IPValue did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the lawsuit.

Realtek said MediaTek signed a patent licensing agreement with IPValue subsidiary Future Link Systems LLC in 2019 that included the secret “bounty” agreement.

The agreement was revealed last year in patent litigation involving Future Link in West Texas federal court and at the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC), according to the lawsuit. Realtek said Future Link has kept details of the agreement “buried under confidentiality obligations and protective orders.”

The ITC called the agreement “alarming” and said it “may well be untoward and actionable,” while the West Texas court said it was “improper” and “should be discouraged as a matter of public policy.”

Future Link settled several other patent cases against tech companies including MediaTek competitor Amlogic soon after the ITC criticized it, Realtek said.

Realtek said MediaTek has used the patent lawsuits, which seek to take its allegedly infringing chips off the market, to suggest to customers that Realtek may be an “unreliable supplier” for the television chip industry.

Realtek asked the court to order the companies to end the alleged conspiracy and requested an unspecified amount of money damages.

The case is Realtek Semiconductor Corp v. MediaTek Inc, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, No. 5:23-cv-02774.

For Realtek: Rudy Kim, Michael Murray and Nafeesah Attah of Paul Hastings; Steven Baik of White Hat Legal

For MediaTek and IPValue: attorney information not available

(Reporting by Blake Brittain in WashingtonAdditional reporting by Ben Blanchard in TaipeiEditing by Mark Potter)