Thames Water financial restructuring proposal amidst Class B creditor dispute - Global Banking & Finance Review
This image illustrates the financial challenges faced by Thames Water, including its restructuring efforts and the conflict with Class B creditors. The article discusses how the utility company aims to stabilize its finances amid competing plans.
Finance

What is meant by Fishing for Trading Systems?

Published by Gbaf News

Posted on May 31, 2012

6 min read

· Last updated: October 17, 2018

Add as preferred source on Google

Key Features of Trading Systems

The quintessential features of a trading system depend primarily upon three categories: Primary, secondary and minor. This theory was postulated by Charles Henry Dow, the founder of the Dow Jones indexes. The primary trend directs the investor towards the path where the prices are flowing. The secondary trend catapults in to the waves responsible for the flow and the minor trends is characterized by their behaviour as ripples on the waves.

Common Discrepancies in Market Analysis

The market analysis usually points out few discrepancies. This article refers to the major two discrepancies:

  1. Most of the times the investor would find interfering trend directions. This can be demonstrated by the fact that a weekly chart can show an ascending trend, although a daily chart would show a descending trend. Notwithstanding, an intraday chart would rather not reflect any direction.
  2. The signals presented by the trend indicators can also be contradictory, which means a trend indicator may point towards an ascending trend; however the oscillator may show the sell signals instead of buy signals to the trader.

Overview of the Triple Screen Trading System

According to Alexander Elder these intervals (large-time and small-time) can be divided and used appropriately to eliminate any contradictions. Dr. Elder postulated a triple screen trading system. It works better than a single screen or indicator as in a single screen trading system the investor has to adhere to a single course of action and that could eventually lead to a faulty pattern leading to losses. Instead, Dr. Elder’s system corresponds to take advantage of the best of both trend-following and oscillator techniques. With the triple trading system, one gets the opportunity to combat the shortcomings of a particular trading position along with the distinctive ramifications of the market.

Time Frame Categorization for Traders

The worrying factor in the trading business is the time frames.  The solution to this issue is to categorize the time frames into units of five. For example, while you deal with monthly charts, you can divide them into weekly charts, i.e. a month has 4.5 weeks. Thus, it becomes easy to move from weekly charts to daily charts, i.e. there are exactly five trading days per week. Moving further, a daily chart can be comfortably divided into hourly charts as there are five to six hours in a trading day. If you are a day trader, you can reduce the hourly chart to a 10 minute chart (denominator of six) and it can easily be converted into a two-minute chart (denominator of five).

With the help of this categorization, a trader gets ample observational skills in terms of watching out on a monthly chart while trading on a weekly manner.

Applying Time Frames to Triple Screen System

In order to implement the analysis of time frames to the concept of triple screen system, the trader has to label this time frame as the intermediate time frame. So if the investor chooses the longer- term time frame, he has to select the order of five longer. Similarly, a trader setting his time frame for a short-term has to employ the order with shorter magnitude. For a better understanding, a day trader holding a position for less than an hour, will use a 10-minute chart as his/her intermediate time frame. In fact, his long-term time frame corresponds to an hourly chart diagnosis and a two-minute chart relates to a short-term time frame.

The quintessential features of a trading system depend primarily upon three categories: Primary, secondary and minor. This theory was postulated by Charles Henry Dow, the founder of the Dow Jones indexes. The primary trend directs the investor towards the path where the prices are flowing. The secondary trend catapults in to the waves responsible for the flow and the minor trends is characterized by their behaviour as ripples on the waves.

The market analysis usually points out few discrepancies. This article refers to the major two discrepancies:

  1. Most of the times the investor would find interfering trend directions. This can be demonstrated by the fact that a weekly chart can show an ascending trend, although a daily chart would show a descending trend. Notwithstanding, an intraday chart would rather not reflect any direction.
  2. The signals presented by the trend indicators can also be contradictory, which means a trend indicator may point towards an ascending trend; however the oscillator may show the sell signals instead of buy signals to the trader.

According to Alexander Elder these intervals (large-time and small-time) can be divided and used appropriately to eliminate any contradictions. Dr. Elder postulated a triple screen trading system. It works better than a single screen or indicator as in a single screen trading system the investor has to adhere to a single course of action and that could eventually lead to a faulty pattern leading to losses. Instead, Dr. Elder’s system corresponds to take advantage of the best of both trend-following and oscillator techniques. With the triple trading system, one gets the opportunity to combat the shortcomings of a particular trading position along with the distinctive ramifications of the market.

The worrying factor in the trading business is the time frames.  The solution to this issue is to categorize the time frames into units of five. For example, while you deal with monthly charts, you can divide them into weekly charts, i.e. a month has 4.5 weeks. Thus, it becomes easy to move from weekly charts to daily charts, i.e. there are exactly five trading days per week. Moving further, a daily chart can be comfortably divided into hourly charts as there are five to six hours in a trading day. If you are a day trader, you can reduce the hourly chart to a 10 minute chart (denominator of six) and it can easily be converted into a two-minute chart (denominator of five).

With the help of this categorization, a trader gets ample observational skills in terms of watching out on a monthly chart while trading on a weekly manner.

In order to implement the analysis of time frames to the concept of triple screen system, the trader has to label this time frame as the intermediate time frame. So if the investor chooses the longer- term time frame, he has to select the order of five longer. Similarly, a trader setting his time frame for a short-term has to employ the order with shorter magnitude. For a better understanding, a day trader holding a position for less than an hour, will use a 10-minute chart as his/her intermediate time frame. In fact, his long-term time frame corresponds to an hourly chart diagnosis and a two-minute chart relates to a short-term time frame.

Key Takeaways

  • “Fishing for trading systems” highlights the risk of data-mining and overfitting when developing trading methods.
  • Alexander Elder’s Triple Screen system mitigates conflicting signals by using three timeframes to align long-, medium- and short‑term trends.
  • The system applies trend-following indicators on longer timeframes and oscillators on intermediate timeframes, with precise entry timing on short timeframes.
  • Employing multiple timeframes improves signal reliability and reduces false entries common in single‑indicator systems.

References

Frequently Asked Questions

What does “fishing for trading systems” mean?
It refers to overfitting or data-mining, where strategies are tailored excessively to past data, resulting in poor real‑world performance.
How does the Triple Screen system avoid overfitting?
By requiring a trade setup to pass analysis across three timeframes—long‑term trend, medium‑term pullback, and short‑term entry—it filters out coincidental or spurious signals.
What indicators are typically used for each screen?
Commonly, trend‑following tools like MACD or EMA are used for the long‑term screen; oscillators like Stochastic, RSI or Force Index for the intermediate; and price‑action/tailing stops for entry timing.

Tags

Related Articles

More from Finance

Explore more articles in the Finance category