Published by Global Banking & Finance Review®
Posted on June 17, 2025
2 min readLast updated: January 23, 2026
Add as preferred source on Google
Erin Patterson denies murdering relatives with toxic mushrooms. The defense claims no motive, while prosecution alleges deception.
By Alasdair Pal
SYDNEY (Reuters) -An Australian woman accused of murdering three elderly relatives of her estranged husband using a meal laced with toxic mushrooms had no motive to kill them, her lawyer told the court on Tuesday as the defence began its closing argument.
Erin Patterson is charged with the murders of her mother-in-law Gail Patterson, father-in-law Donald Patterson and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson, along with the attempted murder of Ian Wilkinson, Heather's husband, in July 2023.
The prosecution accuses her of foraging for poisonous death cap mushrooms, drying them and knowingly serving the mushrooms in individual portions of Beef Wellington at her home in Leongatha, a town of about 6,000 people some 135 km (84 miles) from Melbourne.
Patterson denies the charges, which carry a life sentence, with her defence earlier calling the deaths a "terrible accident".
On Tuesday, Patterson's barrister Colin Mandy said prosecution evidence that the accused's relationship with estranged husband Simon Patterson had soured after a disagreement over child support lacked logic.
"Whatever we might call those spats and disagreements and frustrations, it doesn't provide any kind of motive to murder someone's parents," he told the court.
In fact, the accused had a good relationship with the Patterson family, he added, saying she had loaned Simon Patterson's siblings hundreds of thousands of dollars to buy property.
Earlier on Tuesday, barrister Nanette Rogers ended the prosecution's closing argument by accusing Patterson of a calculated trail of deception before and after the lunch.
"Erin Patterson told so many lies it's hard to keep up with them," Rogers told the court.
"She's told lies upon lies because she knew the truth would implicate her."
After the defence concludes its closing statement, presiding judge Justice Christopher Beale will give his instructions to the jury before it retires to consider a verdict.
The trial, which is now in its eighth week and has gripped Australia, is expected to conclude later this month.
(Reporting by Alasdair Pal in Sydney; Editing by Kate Mayberry)
Erin Patterson is charged with the murders of her mother-in-law, father-in-law, and aunt-in-law, along with the attempted murder of Ian Wilkinson.
The defense argues that Patterson had no motive to kill, citing her good relationship with the Patterson family and financial support she provided to them.
The prosecution accuses Patterson of foraging for poisonous mushrooms and knowingly serving them in a meal, suggesting a calculated deception.
The trial is currently in its eighth week and is expected to conclude later this month.
If convicted, Patterson faces charges that carry a life sentence.
Explore more articles in the Headlines category
