Connect with us

Global Banking and Finance Review is an online platform offering news, analysis, and opinion on the latest trends, developments, and innovations in the banking and finance industry worldwide. The platform covers a diverse range of topics, including banking, insurance, investment, wealth management, fintech, and regulatory issues. The website publishes news, press releases, opinion and advertorials on various financial organizations, products and services which are commissioned from various Companies, Organizations, PR agencies, Bloggers etc. These commissioned articles are commercial in nature. This is not to be considered as financial advice and should be considered only for information purposes. It does not reflect the views or opinion of our website and is not to be considered an endorsement or a recommendation. We cannot guarantee the accuracy or applicability of any information provided with respect to your individual or personal circumstances. Please seek Professional advice from a qualified professional before making any financial decisions. We link to various third-party websites, affiliate sales networks, and to our advertising partners websites. When you view or click on certain links available on our articles, our partners may compensate us for displaying the content to you or make a purchase or fill a form. This will not incur any additional charges to you. To make things simpler for you to identity or distinguish advertised or sponsored articles or links, you may consider all articles or links hosted on our site as a commercial article placement. We will not be responsible for any loss you may suffer as a result of any omission or inaccuracy on the website. .

Business

Going through a ‘business divorce’
Going through a ‘business divorce’

Published : , on

Due to stress, lost clients, pressure, long hours or personal conflicts some SME business relationships can sour over time. But where do you stand if you co-own a business with your partner and you are facing a shareholder dispute? Louise Hebborn, Commercial Partner at Stephensons Solicitors LLP, discusses a shareholder’s legal rights.

There are 5.6 million small businesses[i] in the UK and 96% of these employ fewer than 10 employees[ii]. Sometimes for a variety of reasons the relationship between SME shareholders falls apart – partners can disagree over the direction of a company, the amount taken out in shareholder dividends or the performance of the board. One business partner might feel aggrieved or frozen out and then decide to bring a shareholder dispute case against another.

Here we highlight how to deal with shareholder conflict and explore how a resolution can be achieved to protect the future of the business.

Louise Hebborn

Louise Hebborn

Shareholders’ agreements

Although all business owners, whether they are family, friends or colleagues, start out trusting each other and believing everyone is working towards the same objectives, sometimes over time this can change. That is why it is important to draw up a shareholders’ agreement, a contract between the shareholders of a company, so that everyone knows where they stand from a legal perspective if relationships breakdown.

The purpose of the document is to protect the shareholders’ investment in the company, regulate the day to day running of a business, establish a fair relationship between the shareholders and agree how the business is run. One key point to bear-in-mind is that these terms are private between shareholders and the company, and there is no requirement to file these with Companies House.

While there is no obligation to have a shareholders’ agreement in place, it is strongly recommended to give all parties peace of mind. They are essential to protect an SME’s future and must be reviewed regularly and amended, especially when business ownership changes.

The protection

Understandably not all business ownership is split 50 / 50. There are likely to be minority and majority shareholdings, with various percentages. The terms of the agreement can be drafted in such a way to protect those minority shareholders from being outvoted or prejudiced or allow majority shareholders to act without the entire decision of all shareholders.

It is important to ensure that the agreement is drafted correctly and clauses such as ‘drag-along right’, (DAR) which enables a majority shareholder to force a minority shareholder to join in the sale of a company and ‘tag-along right’ (TAR) the contractual obligations used to protect a minority shareholder, usually in a venture capital deal and other such phrases are considered and where appropriate included.

Unfair prejudice

Unfair prejudice is the procedure by which a minority shareholder, who is the victim of ‘unfairly prejudicial’ conduct by the majority shareholder, can bring court proceedings. However, what constitutes unfair prejudice will depend on the circumstances of each case.

However, some types of behaviour in SME cases are common. For example, actions taken to freeze one shareholder out, either out of management or possibly out of the company. This can occur when the founding shareholders/directors may no longer share the same vision, or one might consider that they are effectively carrying the other.

The remedy for unfair prejudice is often an order than the minority shareholder be bought out of the company but may be the just and equitable winding up of the company depending upon the circumstances.

Act early

If you or a business partner decide to bring a shareholder case forward, try and acknowledge what it is you want to achieve. Do you want to resolve the dispute and stay working in this company?  Or do you want to take your partner to court and potentially irrevocably harm your relationship?

It is prudent to seek advice in the early stages of a decision like this and assess your options. Firstly, a solicitor will determine if you have a shareholder agreement in place. Do not agree to resign as a director, or volunteer to leave the role in the company, as these actions can have an impact on the value of your shares and remove an element of the claim you might have for unfair prejudice.

Seek legal advice first and don’t settle or agree to anything without getting professional guidance.

A compromise

A negotiated separation through mediation is the smoothest way to exit a shareholder business agreement and minimise legal costs, without damaging relationships or reputation.

Mediation is confidential and without prejudice, which means both parties are free to negotiate with the mediator to agree a joint settlement. The role of the mediator is to act as a trusted, independent person who has the ear of both parties and can encourage communication.

The mediator will not make decisions or force an agreement but helps both shareholders to reach a compromise. If a resolution is agreed, it’s worthwhile including it in the shareholder agreement to try to avoid future disputes.

Moving on

It is nearly always the best outcome for both the company and the shareholders to resolve disputes quickly and without the need to forge ahead with litigation. These situations are often sensitive and professional external mediation can often defuse disagreements in the early stages.

If negotiation is unsuccessful and a claim is brought forward one common feature of this type of case, is that the aggrieved business shareholder tends to do something drastic designed to harm a former partner. For example, setting up a competitor company, re-directing work away from the company or removing assets. This is often done as an act of retribution and usually results in a counter-claim being brought against them when pursuing their claim for unfair prejudice.

To prevent a shareholder dispute careful succession planning is key, spend time drawing-up a water-tight shareholder agreement and put in place corporate structures to help avoid disputes.

[i]https://www.fsb.org.uk/media-centre/small-business-statistics

[ii]https://www.merchantsavvy.co.uk/uk-sme-data-stats-charts/

Uma Rajagopal has been managing the posting of content for multiple platforms since 2021, including Global Banking & Finance Review, Asset Digest, Biz Dispatch, Blockchain Tribune, Business Express, Brands Journal, Companies Digest, Economy Standard, Entrepreneur Tribune, Finance Digest, Fintech Herald, Global Islamic Finance Magazine, International Releases, Online World News, Luxury Adviser, Palmbay Herald, Startup Observer, Technology Dispatch, Trading Herald, and Wealth Tribune. Her role ensures that content is published accurately and efficiently across these diverse publications.

Global Banking & Finance Review

 

Why waste money on news and opinions when you can access them for free?

Take advantage of our newsletter subscription and stay informed on the go!


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: . You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Recent Post