Analysis: Foreigners Suspend Disbelief, Edge Back Into Turkish Markets

By Nevzat Devranoglu, Rodrigo Campos and Jonathan Spicer

ANKARA/NEW YORK (Reuters) – Foreign investors who for years saw Turkey as a lost cause of economic mismanagement are edging back in, drawn by the promise of some of the biggest returns in emerging markets if President Tayyip Erdogan stays true to a pledge of reforms.

More than $15 billion has streamed into Turkish assets since November when Erdogan – long sceptical of orthodox policymaking and quick to scapegoat outsiders – abruptly promised a new market-friendly era and installed a new central bank chief.

Interviews with more than a dozen foreign money managers and Turkish bankers say those inflows could double by mid-year, especially if larger investment funds take longer-term positions, following on the heels of fleet-footed hedge funds.

“We’re very encouraged to see a different approach coming in,” said Polina Kurdyavko, London-based head of emerging markets (EMs) at BlueBay Asset Management, which manages $67 billion.

“We have added to our exposure and we plan to keep it that way as long as we continue to see the orthodox steps.”

Turkey’s asset valuations and real rates are among the most attractive globally. It is also lifted by a wave of optimism over coronavirus vaccines and economic rebound that pushed EM inflows to their highest level since 2013 in the fourth quarter, according to the Institute of International Finance.

But for Turkey, once a darling among EM investors, market scepticism runs deep.

The lira has shed half its value since a currency crisis in mid-2018 set off a series of economic policies that shunned foreign investment, badly depleted the country’s FX reserves and eroded the central bank’s independence.

The currency touched a record low in early November a day before Nagi Agbal took the bank’s reins. The question is whether he can keep his job and patiently battle against near 15% inflation despite Erdogan’s repeated criticism of high rates.

Agbal has already hiked interest rates to 17% from 10.25% and promised even tighter policy if needed.

After all but abandoning Turkish assets in recent years, some foreign investors are giving the hawkish monetary stance and other recent regulatory tweaks the benefit of the doubt.

Foreign bond ownership has rebounded in recent months above 5%, from 3.5%, though it is well off the 20% of four years ago and remains one of the smallest foreign footprints of any EM.

ERDOGAN SCEPTICS

Six Turkish bankers told Reuters they expect foreigners to hold 10% of the debt by mid-year on between $7 to 15 billion of inflows. Deutsche Bank sees about $10 billion arriving.

Some long-term investors “are cozying up to the idea of being long Turkey but it’s a long process,” said one banker, requesting anonymity.

Paris-based Carmignac, which manages $45 billion in assets, may take the plunge after a year away.

“There could be some value in Turkish assets and we have started to look with a little bit more interest especially with the very high rates,” said Joseph Mouawad, emerging debt fund manager at the firm.

“It is still a hairy market to invest in but for sure, relative to what has been happening in the last 18 months, things have dramatically shifted and … that has a lot to do with the people running the economic policy,” he said.

Turkish stocks have rallied 33% to records since the shock November leadership overhaul that also saw Erdogan’s son-in-law Berat Albayrak resign as finance minister.

He oversaw a policy of lira interventions that cut the central bank’s net FX reserves by two thirds in a year, leaving Turkey desperate for foreign funding and teeing up Erdogan’s policy reversal.

In another bullish signal, Agbal’s monetary tightening has lifted Turkey’s real rate from deep in negative territory to 2.4%, compared to an EM average of 0.5%.

But a day after the central bank promised high rates for an “extended period,” Erdogan told a forum on Friday he is “absolutely against” them.

The president fired the last two bank chiefs over policy disagreement and often repeats the unorthodox view that high rates cause inflation.

“Investors didn’t expect the leopard to have changed his spots and he hasn’t. I suspect people will be feeling Erdogan’s influence by mid-2021” when rates will be cut too soon, said Charles Robertson, London-based global chief economist at Renaissance Capital.

Turks are among the most sceptical of Erdogan’s economic reform promises. Stung by years of double-digit food inflation, eroded wealth and a boom-bust economy, they have bought up a record $235 billion in hard currencies.

Many investors say only a reversal in this dollarisation will rehabilitate the reputation of Turkey, whose weight has dipped to below 1% in the popular MSCI EM index.

“Turkey can’t be a long-term investment for portfolio investors because they will expect the rinse-and-repeat process … that we’ve seen so many times in the last 15 to 20 years,” Renaissance’s Robertson said.

(Additional reporting by Karin Strohecker in London and Dominic Evans in Istanbul; Editing by William Maclean)