The US dollar index has been in the downtrend since the start of 2017. The most sizeable correction to the upside took place in September-October. After that, the slide resumed. The greenback fell to the lowest levels since the end of 2014.
From the first sight, this trend in the currency market doesn’t look logical: the American economy is doing fine and the central bank is in course of a hiking cycle. What causes the depreciation of the US currency?
Donald Trump’s goal was to make America great again. As an entrepreneur, he is certainly an encouraging figure for businesses.
US economy is indeed in a rather good shape after the first year of his presidency. Average annualized GDP growth rate equals to 3%. There are opinions that Trump has just been lucky. The US economy had already been on the right track before Trump arrived, and the Federal Reserve should take credit for things like the decline in unemployment to 4.1% in December 2017. Plus, the global economy is growing at a nice pace and that contributes to the US economic momentum as well.
Will the United States manage to sustain the recent growth pace and even increase it as Trump has promised? That depends on whether the authorities manage to ignite consumer spending and labor productivity.
The productivity of American firms and workers rose by 1.2%, rebounding from a 0.1% drop in 2016. Still, that’s low compared with average annual increases seen in 2000-2006. US consumer spending rose solidly in December. At the same time, savings fell to a 10-year low – a troubling sign for future consumption and economic growth.
US economic policy is the key
A more thorough analysis leads to an assumption that the economic policy of the US government is the main factor responsible for the dollar’s weakness. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said in Davos that a weaker dollar is good for the United States. Although he later said that he was misunderstood, the scope of market’s reaction to the news shows that traders take the intentions of the US government seriously.
Donald Trump has been active in terms of economic policymaking. One of his main projects is the tax reform: US corporate income tax rates were finally lowered to an internationally competitive level. However, it remains to be seen how many actual benefits the reform will bring. Specialists at Moody’s Investors Service doubt that the tax overhaul will boost business investment. There’s a risk that companies will more likely reward shareholders than invest in growth, and tax cuts for the rich won’t encourage higher consumption.
Another feature of Trump’s policy is trade protectionism under the “America-first” banner. The president’s administration imposed a punitive tariff on imported solar panels and foreign washing machines to make life easier for domestic producers.
There’s also a risk that the US will withdraw from the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) with Mexico and Canada. According to the research of Oxford Economics, such step in 2018 would reduce US GDP growth by 0.5 percentage point in 2019, while Trump’s goal of diminishing US trade deficit won’t be reached.
Such actions pursue a populistic goal: to find an external source of problems and try to achieve quick improvement by punishing it. A strategy like this may have far-reaching and unwelcome consequences. The escalation of trade tensions may lead China to take retaliatory actions. The recent data showed that in November China reduced its holdings of US Treasury bonds to a 4-month minimum. There are reports that China was planning on slowing or even halting the accumulation of the US debt – bad news for the USD.
The desire to solve domestic economic problems at the expense of other countries might have a negative impact on global economic growth and revive currency wars, in which countries compete by devaluing their currencies.
US dollar as the whipping boy
The Federal Reserve went far ahead of other central banks in policy normalization. The regulator raised rates three times in 2017. The same number of rate hikes is expected this year. However, it turns out that monetary policy tightening doesn’t lead to the stronger dollar anymore. US yields rose, but 90-day correlations between 2-year US-Germany yield spread and EUR/USD fell to a minimum since the end of 2015.
The thing is that the US rates are still not high enough to attract investors which now have plenty of other opportunities. The robust economic growth made many traders choose to buy the soaring stocks over the fixed-income instruments like bonds. Moreover, although weak dollar helps US exports, it devalues all types of American assets. European equities are taking advantage of it: the region accounted for more than a third of global equity fund flows in 2017.
In addition, the lower the USD falls, the more sense global central banks and sovereign wealth funds have to diversify from it. Dollar reserves fell from 66% in 2015 to 63% in September 2017.
It’s also necessary to mention that markets live by expectations. For several months now, investor minds were fixed on the idea that the European Central Bank will move towards the end of its monetary stimulus program. Traders have been vigorously reacting to the positive news from the euro area hunted for policy normalization signals in the ECB statements. The Federal Reserve’s rate hikes, on the other hand, were quickly priced in and excited no one’s imagination.
The new year will certainly bring uncertainty. The ECB may start expressing displeasure with the strong euro or inflation in G10 will finally gain pace so that everyone will be tightening. A new person will take the reins of the Fed. Although many investors think that Jerome Powell’s approach will be very similar to that of Janet Yellen, no one can know that for sure.
US core consumer prices recorded their largest increase in 11 months in December, rising 0.3%. Economists hope that a tightening labor market, rising commodity prices, a weak dollar and fiscal stimulus will lift inflation toward the Fed’s 2% target this year. The Fed also said at its January meeting that it expects a pickup in inflation. If so, the Fed will remain on the tightening track. It’s necessary to understand, though, that continuation of rate hikes at the current pace is not a serious bullish driver for the USD, it just doesn’t let it sink faster.
From the technical point of view, DXY fell to a new range and will have a hard time returning above 92.00. Support levels – or downside targets – are at 86.50, 84.70 and 80.00 as a more long-term landmark.
As the bond guru Jeff Gundlach said, “usually when you get a bad year in the dollar, it’s followed by one or two more bad years”. That is surely just an arbitrary observation, which shouldn’t be taken as a call to short the greenback. Yet, there are many reasons to think that 2018 will be the year of vigorous economic growth, strong euro and high commodity prices. That is, of course, if S&P bubble doesn’t burst and make everyone flee to safe havens.