Research Reports
Insolvency report: No rest for the leveraged
Global Banking and Finance Review
Company
Authors: Maxime Lemerle Maria Latorre, Ano Kuhanathan
Authors: Maxime Lemerle Maria Latorre, Ano Kuhanathan
Figure 1: Global and regional insolvency indices, yearly level, basis 100 in 2019
Source: Allianz Research
Figure 2: Global and regional insolvencies indexes, yearly change in %
Source: Allianz Research
As expected, the rebound in business insolvencies is intensifying for a growing number of countries. After two years of decline globally during the pandemic years (-14% and -11% in 2020 and 2021, respectively), our Global Insolvency Index bounced back quarter after quarter in 2022, with the trend reversal exceeding double-digits in Q3 (+14% y/y) and Q4 (+11% y/y) – see Figure 3. For the full year, business insolvencies rose by +9% (adjusted to +2% when considering the change in source for Turkey). This rebound was largely expected, given the ending of support measures related to the pandemic and the shockwaves from the war in Ukraine, as well as the prolonged lockdowns in China, which affected supply chains and input prices.
Figure 3: Global and regional insolvency index, quarterly change, y/y in %
Source: Allianz Research
Three out of four countries we analyze posted a rebound in insolvencies for the full year 2022. This outcome – see Figure 4 – represents a doubling compared to 2021.
In 2022, Western Europe saw noticeable double-digit rises in Austria (+57% y/y), the UK (+51%) and France (+48%) – all three among the countries that recorded the largest drop in insolvencies in 2020/2021. Seven other countries saw insolvencies rising by more than +10% annually: Belgium, Denmark, Ireland, the Netherlands, Norway, Spain and Switzerland. In Central and Eastern Europe, the rebound was led by Hungary (+67%), Lithuania (+56%) and Poland (+20%). In Asia, it was led by India (+50%) and Australia (+45%), while in the Americas, the rebound reached +35% in Canada. However, in each region, at least one country recorded another decrease in insolvencies, notably China (-13% y/y) and South Korea (-19%) in Asia, the US (-6%) and Brazil (-28%) in the Americas, Italy (-20%) and Portugal (-12%) in Western Europe and Czechia (-17%) and Russia (-12%) in Central and Eastern Europe.
Figure 4: 2022 business insolvencies, annual change in %
Source: Allianz Research
BOX: Major insolvencies continue to increase.
The overall number of insolvencies mostly represents the situation of Small and Medium Enterprises. However, we now see more evidence of the uptick in insolvencies spreading to large firms. Given their long list of suppliers, this implies a larger risk of domino effects. At the global level, the number of major insolvencies reached 88 cases in Q4 2022 (see Figure 5), slightly above pre-pandemic levels. Three sectors contributed the most to the global count for both Q4 and the full year 2022: construction (19 cases in Q4 and 64 for the full year), retail (14 and 33 cases, respectively) and services (10 and 30 cases, respectively).
Recent data point to the same direction for early 2023. In France, business insolvencies of firms with turnover exceeding EUR15mn (+41% for the last 12 months as of February 2023) is gradually closing the gap with the momentum of insolvencies of all other firms (+51%). In the US, (see Figure 6), the rebound is clear when looking at Capital IQ and Bloomberg monitoring : the former records 183 bankruptcy filings in the first quarter of 2023 (i.e. more than the double compared to Q1 2022) after 117 cases in Q4 2022 (+38% y/y) and 211 cases in H2 2022 (+15% y/y); the latter indicates the strongest start of the year since 2009 in Q1 with 55 cases (compared to 12 in Q1 2021 and less than 30 in the previous two quarters).
Figure 5: Major insolvencies, global number, quarterly by size of turnover
Source: Allianz Trade
Figure 6: Insolvencies of large firms in the US, 3m rolling, in number
Sources: Bloomberg, Capital IQ, Allianz Research
Western Europe is (so far) the largest contributor to the global rebound in insolvencies, boosted by the catch-up in transport and storage, trade, accommodation and food services activities and B2C services. For the full year 2022, Western Europe contributed three times more than Asia to the global rise in insolvencies due to its share in our headline indicator (38% and 24%, respectively) and the changes in regional insolvency index (+22% and +5%). It is worth noticing that this recovery is spreading across sectors despite its heterogeneity. Looking at the full year 2022 (see Table 1), after a sharp catch-up in the last quarter, business bankruptcies increased in at least five out of the eight large sectors representing the overall economy for most European countries – compared to two to three sectors in H1 2022. In Belgium, France, Spain and the UK, the rebound is visible in all sectors, while in the Netherlands and Norway it affected seven sectors and in Germany six. Construction and transportation/storage are the two sectors most concerned in terms of number of countries, ahead of manufacturing. Yet, on average, the largest increases in insolvencies at the EU level are seen in transportation/storage (+44% y/y), trade (+20%), accommodation and food services activities (+20%) and B2C services (+17%) – with construction (+6%) and manufacturing (+5%) lagging.
Table 1: Europe: Business bankruptcies by sector, 2022, y/y change in % (selected countries)
Sources: National sources, Eurostat, Allianz Research
The first available data for January and February 2023 confirm that the rising trend is set to continue. In Q4 2022, the rebound in insolvencies was still on track for three out of four countries (compared to one out of two countries in the first half of 2022). Importantly, the US (+12% and +11% in Q3 and Q4) and Germany (+8% and +19%, respectively) joined the club, leaving Latin America as the only region not posting an upside trend in the last quarter of 2022. Data from January and February (see Table 2) show another set of countries seeing an acceleration in insolvencies, notably the Netherlands, the Nordics and the Baltics in Europe, and Japan and Australia in Asia. In this context, the number of markets with a prolonged low level of insolvencies is mechanically reducing, now limited to China, Brazil and Italy, as well as the special case of Russia where the ‘war economy’ has so far succeeded in offsetting the ending of the insolvency moratorium.
Table 2: Business insolvencies – 2023 figures available as of end-March in America/Western Europe (left) and Central and Eastern Europe/Asia/Africa (right)
Sources: National sources, Allianz Research. Data for Spain are not representative due to strikes limiting the official opening of proceedings.
The spillover of financial stability concerns has increased corporate risks and will contribute to the broad-based acceleration in business insolvencies in 2023. Fears of recession have abated and supply-chain issues have eased. But companies are still facing extended pressure on the profitability side amid tighter-for-longer financial conditions, given the turmoil in the US and European banking sector. Overall, the balance of risks has slightly deteriorated.
#1: The ‘normalization’ is not complete yet, especially in Europe. Covid-19 related support measures have been largely phased out but in several countries firms remain engaged in a multi-year reimbursement process for specific measures such as KfW loans in Germany and the ‘Prêts Garantis par l’Etat’ (aka ‘PGE) in France. In addition, they have to face the gradual ending of additional support measures implemented in the wake of the war in Ukraine, in particular regarding energy prices.
Elsewhere, as governments tighten spending, we expect a return to normal business conditions. This will put those companies that were already fragile before the pandemic and energy shock further at risk, alongside those that have not been able to adapt their business models to the structural changes created or intensified by the successive crises (“zombie firms”).
De facto, one out of three countries still did not return to their pre-pandemic levels of insolvencies in 2022. Western Europe stands out with two out of three countries lagging, notably the Netherlands (with FY 200-43% below 2019), Italy (-36%), Germany (-22%), France (-19%) and Belgium (-13%). Overall, we counted a rebound in insolvencies in slightly less than 60% of the industries in Europe, with a return to pre-pandemic levels for only 22% of them in annual terms, mainly in accommodation/food services, transport/storage and B2C services. Conversely, this means a noticeable potential for normalization in the remaining sectors.
Figure 7: Business bankruptcies by sector, EU index, seasonally adjusted, quarterly levels
Sources: National sources, Eurostat, Allianz Research
Demand is likely to remain well below the minimum required to at least stabilize the number of insolvencies. We expect global growth to slow in 2023 (+2.2%) and recover modestly in 2024 (+2.3%). The US will not be able to avoid a recession at the end of 2022, while the Eurozone growth is expected to see a shallow recovery in 2024 (+0.9%) after a subdued expansion in 2023 (+0.3%). In most cases, the outlook for GDP momentum for 2023 and 2024 is below the levels required to lead a decrease in insolvencies (see Figure 8).
Based on those long-term sensitivities, we calculate that the Eurozone and the US would need 1.3pp and 1.5pp in additional GDP growth on average in 2023-2024 to stabilize the number of insolvencies. This GDP gap will be smaller in 2023 than in 2024 for the US (1.2pp and 1.9, respectively). Conversely, the Eurozone will see a larger gap in 2023 than in 2024 (1.6pp and 1.0pp, respectively), with a noticeable dispersion across countries, particularly in 2023 (from 0.6pp for Germany and 1.1p for France to more than 2.0pp for the UK, Spain and the Nordics).
Figure 8: Level of GDP stabilizing insolvencies versus 2023-2024 GDP forecasts, US and selected European countries
(*) GDP threshold: GDP growth momentum required to stabilize the number of insolvencies prior to the pandemic
Source: Allianz Research
The latest earning season (Q4 2022) confirmed the deterioration of the performance of listed companies, with revenues growing on average by +4.0% y/y and earnings per share (EPS) declining by -5.0% y/y, compared to +15% and +13% in Q1, respectively – with several sectors clearly underperforming at a global level, notably metals/mining and chemicals. We expect elevated inputs costs to persist, along with a prolonged recovery in wages and the long-lasting effects of rising interest rates.
This combination of factors will mechanically increase corporate risks at a time when weakening global demand reduces firms’ ability to pass on price increases to customers, unlike in 2022. To add to this, the increase in working capital requirements recorded in 2022 (see Figure 9), notably in machinery and transport equipment, is here to stay.
High cash balances provided a significant buffer, with the cash hoardings of non-financials well above pandemic levels in the Eurozone (EUR3,427bn as of February 2023 i.e. +33% compared to January 2020) and in the US (USD2,070bn as of end-2022 i.e. +19% compared to January 2020). However, our cash-burning index turned negative since the first half of 2022 for the US and most European countries (see Figure 10), suggesting that this buffer is being depleted. Moreover, not all sectors benefited from high cash holdings.
All in all, we expect the most fragile sectors and firms will be hit the hardest, including:
Figure 9: Q4 2022 earnings season: Revenue and EPS growth
Sources: Refinitiv, Allianz Research
Figure 10: 2022 WCR, by global sectors, listed firms in number of days of turnover
Sources: Refinitiv, Allianz Research
Figure 11: Cash-burning index, selected countries
Source: Bloomberg, Eikon Refinitiv, ECB, BoE, FRED, Allianz Research
Overall, we expect a sharp acceleration in business insolvencies globally in 2023 (+21% y/y) before another – though more limited – rise in 2024 (+4%). This escalation would push half of the countries above their pre-pandemic number of insolvencies in 2023, and three out of five in 2024 (see Figure 11). In 2023, the acceleration would be broad-based, with all countries to contribute to the upside and the largest increases in France (+41%), the US (+49%) and the Netherlands (+52%). 2024 would see a first set of countries with insolvencies close to stabilizing or already declining, most often after a strong bounce-back over 2021-2023 and/or from a historic high. Yet, we expect the majority of countries (three out of four) to continue to see surging insolvencies (increases between +2% and 10% for half of them).
In Western Europe, we expect insolvencies to post a relatively strong increase in 2023 (+20%), for the third consecutive year (+5% in 2020 and +22% in 2021), and to stabilize in 2024 (+0%). Despite mixed dynamics, the region already crossed its pre-pandemic level in 2022 (by +3%) and will see additional increases in all countries in 2023. In 2024, the region is set to record 25% more insolvencies than in 2019.
In Germany the upside trend reversal in insolvencies started (much) later than in most other European countries, partly thanks to massive state support. The gradual deterioration of the economic and financial outlook set the stage for a noticeable cross-sector increase in Q4 2022 (+19% y/y). While early 2023 alternative figures are pointing to the upside, we expect the rebound in insolvencies to gain traction with the weaker business environment and the tighter financial context, reaching +22% in 2023 (i.e. +3,210 firms to 17,800 cases) and +6% in 2024 (i.e. +1,100 firms to 18,900). As a result, we expect German to reach the 2019 level of insolvencies before the end of 2023.
France is on track for another strong jump in insolvencies in 2023 (+41%), the continuation of the normalization that began in 2022 (+48%), amid a deterioration of the balance of risks, notably regarding (re)financing issues. Sectors that have been lagging in the normalization – notably construction which is historically the major contributor to the total count – are expected to support the dynamic so far boosted by hotels/restaurants, manufacturing and trade. We expect insolvencies to reach 59,000 cases in France in 2023 (i.e. +17,100 cases), before a limited decrease in 2024 (-2,000), though insolvencies will still be 11% higher than the 2019 level.
In Italy, business insolvencies should start to catch up in 2023 (+23% i.e. + 1,790 cases) and 2024 (+10% i.e. +1,100 cases) due to the weaker economic environment and the new legal context created by the Codice della crisi e dell’insolvenza (namely the composizione negoziata della crisi). Yet, a return to the pre-pandemic level is not expected by 2024 since local experts record a greater inclination to use out-of-court proceedings to reach agreements with debtors. Moreover, the rebound is taking place from the low level reached in 2022 (7,164 cases – the lowest annual count since 2008) as the post-lockdown recovery and the various state support measures successfully contained the number of insolvencies in all sectors (from -9% y/y for agriculture and hotels/restaurants to more than -20% in the majority of sectors).
The UK faces a high risk of a prolonged upside trend in 2023 (+16% i.e. +3,930 cases) and 2024 (+9% i.e. +2,600). Domestic firms have had to deal with a fragile context amid a sharp growth deceleration, earlier monetary tightening and rapid inflation – in addition to specific Brexit-related issues. As a result, insolvencies quickly bounced back in the UK with the phasing-out of support measures (+4% in 2021 and +51% in 2022) across all sectors from +27% y/y in 2022 for transportation/storage to +69% for trade). We expect business insolvencies to continue to exceed the pre-pandemic level, gradually closing the gap with 2011 highs by 2024 (to 31,100 cases), albeit still below the 2009 records.
In Central and Eastern Europe and Africa/Middle East, we expect business insolvencies to be noticeably above their pre-pandemic regional levels as soon as 2023 (+13% and +44%, respectively). We should see additional increases in 2023 in particular in Turkey (+50%), the Baltics (+41% in average) and to a lesser extent in Poland (+20%), with a more limited increase in South Africa (+7%) and Morocco (+5%). In Russia, as the government still has the financial means to maintain support for firms, we expect a prolonged low number of business insolvencies in 2023, potentially close to the low posted in 2022 (i.e. 9,500 cases). However, insolvencies are at risk of seeing a catch-up with the end of the government’s (financial) abilities and (political) willingness to support businesses.
In Asia, China succeeded in keeping the official number of business insolvencies under control in 2022 (-13% y/y to 7,530 cases) despite a challenging year with multiple lockdowns and a large number of major failures. However, business insolvencies should see a moderate increase (+4% in 2023 and +5% in 2024) as the reopening has not erased all risks, notably in the real estate and construction sectors.
The other countries in the region should see more insolvencies due to the downside factors affecting the region (e.g. elevated interest rates and inflation), notably Australia (+15% in 2023 after +45% in 2022), Japan (+12% in 2023 after +7% in 2022) and India (+36% in 2023 after +50% in 2022 due to the catch-up from the long suspension of courts). Overall, Asia and Latin America will be the only two regions not back to 2019 levels in insolvencies by 2024, despite seeing an increase in 2023 (+12% and +20%, respectively) and in 2024 (+5% and +3%, respectively).
In the US, we expect business insolvencies to increase by +49% in 2023 and +15% in 2024 as a result of tighter credit conditions and the sharp slowdown. At this stage, this will mean a return to 20,000+ insolvencies per year in 2023 and 23,000+ in 2024. This still represents the 2016-2020 average and a low level from a historical perspective, the legacy of buffers accumulated since the pandemic, helped by the recovery in profits and the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP), which saw government-guaranteed loans massively transformed into subsidies. However, the recovery would need to be revised up significantly in case of a deeper recession, or extra challenges in the housing or credit markets.
Figure 12: 2023-2024 expected number of insolvencies, selected countries, basis 100: 2019
Source: Allianz Research
Figure 13: 2024 expected number of insolvencies compared to 2019, by country, in %
Source: Allianz Research
The recent banking turmoil has been a stark reminder of 2008-9 when the financial crisis acted as a massive catalyst for insolvencies. There are five major factors that can put a company in trouble as summarized in Figure 14.
Figure 14:
Source: Allianz Research
Clues from the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) indicate that smaller-sized firms with high leverage and low diversification are the most vulnerable. During the GFC, global insolvencies increased quite sharply (+42% between 2007 and 2009, according to the IMF). The largest increases occurred in advanced economies (i.e. the US, the UK and Spain), with firms in financial services and construction most impacted. We should also underline that the GFC had a particularly severe impact on SMEs, which are particularly vulnerable to large economic downturns for a number of reasons: (i) they are less diversified in terms of products and clients (i.e. most rely on a handful of products sold to a limited number of clients to generate their revenues. (ii) They have weaker financial structures (i.e. lower equity, lower credit rating etc.). (iii) They are highly dependent on credit while having fewer financing options (mostly through banks). (iv) Because they are already small, they cannot downsize or run at lower capacity.
A replication of the GFC shock, based on the difference between the final outcome in insolvencies for 2008-2009 and the forecasts for the same period done prior to the GFC (mid 2007), would boost our insolvencies forecast by an additional +50pps and +30pps in the US in 2023 and 2024, respectively, and by +25pps and +20pps in Western Europe. In terms of the number of insolvencies, this would mean 21,600 additional cases in the US over 2023 and 2024, and 99,900 in Western Europe.
Figure 15: Baseline vs GFC-replication scenario, in number of business insolvencies, US (left) and Western Europe (right)
Source: Allianz Research
During the GFC, the growth in credit to the private sector dropped suddenly from over +10% y/y in mid-2008 to -9% early 2010 in the US, and from +10% to -1% in the Eurozone (declines of -19pps and -11pps, respectively). However, a credit crunch can occur even without a full-blown financial crisis. For instance, during the tech bubble burst of the early 2000s, credit growth declined by -12pps in the US and -8pps in the Eurozone. And during the Eurozone debt crisis, the region experienced a -6pps decline in loans to the private sector.
Figure 15: Credit to the private sector (y/y%)
Sources: Refinitiv, Allianz Research
If we were to witness a credit crunch of the magnitude seen in the early 2000s, insolvencies forecast would increase by +31pps in the US and +22pps in Western Europe in 2023, and by +16pps and +18pps in 2024, respectively. This would mean 12,900 additional cases in the US over 2023 and 2024, and 95,300 in Western Europe. In case of a credit “freeze” that would stop new loans (bring credit growth down to 0), insolvencies would increase by an additional 10,700 cases in the US and 46,300 cases in Europe over 2023 and 2024.
Figure 17: Baseline vs credit crunch scenario, in number of business insolvencies, US (left) and Western Europe (right)
Source: Allianz Research
STATISTICAL APPENDIX
[1] Covering 44 countries that account for 85% of global GDP 2022, see statistical appendix.
[2] Our new source for Turkey gives an accurate monitoring of insolvencies based on the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette by computing bankruptcies and composition agreements instead of liquidations/closing of companies.
[3] See our previous Global Insolvency Report
[4] For business demographic fundamentals i.e. the limited share of major firms.
[5] Firms with an annual turnover exceeding EUR50mn, based on the reporting of Allianz Trade business units.
[6] Bloomberg: Firms with more than USD50mn in liabilities at the time of the bankruptcy filing; Capital IQ: Firms with public debt where either assets or liabilities at the time of the bankruptcy filing are greater than or equal to USD2mn, or private companies where either assets or liabilities at the time of the bankruptcy filing are greater than or equal to USD10mn.
[7] See our previous report on Russia
[8] See our report Everything everywhere all at once
[9] See our reportUS: Credit crunch in the making?
[10] Period of reference: 1989-2019 (US), 1991-2019 (Switzerland), 1993-2019 (France, Spain), 1995-2019 (Sweden), 1997-2019 (Denmark, Italy, Norway, UK), 2001-2019 (Austria, Belgium, Germany, Netherlands, Portugal and Eurozone)
[11] In our previous report we estimated that (i) an additional interest rate increase of 200bps could dent margins by -1.5pp in the US, -2.2pps in the UK and -3pps in the Eurozone, with Italy, Spain and France most affected, and (ii) an increase of the wage bill by 4-5% could cost -0.5pp to -1pp of margins in Europe
[12] See our previous report Mind the gap: The USD30trn global liquidity gap is here to stay
[13] Our cash-burning index, calculated at country level, is the difference in tempo between the change in activity (using nominal GDP as proxy) and the change in net cash position (the latter being measured by the difference between NFC deposits and NFC new loans (up to EUR1mn)). A negative figure indicates a cash-depletion period while a positive figure indicates a period of cash accumulation.
[14] In 2022, China recorded nine out of the ten top insolvencies of the world (in terms of turnovers), with seven firms in the construction sector, and 14 out of the 20 insolvencies of companies with turnovers exceeding EUR1bn.
Insolvency is a financial state where an individual or organization cannot meet its debt obligations. It can lead to bankruptcy if debts are not resolved.
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) measures the total economic output of a country. It reflects the value of all goods and services produced over a specific time period.
Credit management involves the process of managing a company's credit policies and procedures to minimize financial risk and ensure timely payments from customers.
A financial crisis is a situation where financial assets suddenly lose a large part of their nominal value, often leading to widespread economic instability.
Business insolvencies occur when a company is unable to pay its debts as they come due, often resulting in legal proceedings or liquidation.
Explore more articles in the Research Reports category
