By Matt Savare and Kurt Watkins
- Unless you have been living under a rock for the last year, you have heard and read about Bitcoin, which is electronic cash supported by a peer-to-peer network of computers linked via the Internet. Although Bitcoin receives the lion’s share of the press – and is the most valuable cryptocurrency by market capitalization – another such network, Ethereum, is powering a transformation in the way business is conducted. Ethereum is an open source blockchain platform that utilizes a Turing-complete programming language (i.e., capable of computing anything that is computable given sufficient resources) that enables the creation of decentralized applications and “smart contracts.” Without being hyperbolic, smart contracts, which automate business processes using blockchain technology, have the potential to disrupt and revolutionize the provision of business services the same way robots did manufacturing.
Rise of the (Decentralized) Machines
- Today, businesses typically store their information on centralized servers(their own or those of cloud service providers) and share that data with the central servers of third parties, such as banks, vendors, and customers. Such a centralized-server model has three fundamental weaknesses: (1) the costs and inefficiencies associated with having to reconcile data sets;(2) the vulnerability of the central locations to cyber-attacks; and (3) the necessary provision of sensitive data to third parties who facilitate information sharing. A new model based on the blockchain has arrived.
- Blockchain technology obviates the need for centralized servers. Instead, data is transacted and stored in a decentralized or “distributed” fashion using the combination of four elements: nodes, a shared ledger, a consensus mechanism, and a virtual machine, which together comprise a “blockchain.”
- Nodes are computing devices connected to the Internet and running the blockchain software. They represent the physical element of a blockchain and store all of its information. The diffusion of information across the various individual nodes is what makes the blockchain decentralized.
- The shared ledger is the information stored on each of the nodes. Any transaction, or specified group of transactions, is grouped into a “block” of information, and each block is cryptographically linked (or chained) to the adjacent blocks, hence the name blockchain. Together, these transactions and the blocks that store and connect them are the shared ledger. Each node powering the blockchain maintains an identical copy of the shared ledger in its entirety (i.e., each block on the blockchain from the very first block to the very last one). Because reconciliation of the shared ledger is automatic and simultaneous across the entire blockchain, the shared ledger is a single store of truth in an otherwise trustless, decentralized environment.
- The consensus mechanism is the algorithm the blockchain uses to automatically guarantee properly functioning nodes and data transactions. There are a variety of consensus algorithms (e.g., proof-of-work and proof-of-stake), but each one ensures the consistency of the data across all the nodes in a blockchain and ensures those nodes are behaving normally. Should any one node be compromised, the algorithm will recognize it as behaving abnormally and instruct the remaining nodes to take corrective measures. Further, if an improper data transaction occurs, the additional security provided by the cryptographic links will forbid the impropriety.
- The virtual machine is what processes the instructions for the blockchain. It is, in essence, the computer that would exist if all the nodes of the blockchain were contained in a single computer.
The first functional platform to realize these advantages for broad application was Ethereum. Although Ethereum issues tokens (Ether) that can be used for payments, its core value emanates from the ability of its virtual machine to process data transactions and decentralized applications rather than simply exchange tokens, like Bitcoin does. This enhanced functionality enables Ethereum to power and process smart contracts, presenting businesses with two critical advantages: a massive reduction in overhead and greater reliability than current technology models.
Automatic for the People: The Emergence of Smart Contracts
Although there is no definitive definition of “smart contracts,” they are, at the most fundamental level, programs (or “autonomous agents” as the Ethereum white paper dubs them) that execute instructions exactly as programmed. After they are developed and deployed onto the blockchain network, smart contracts are self-executing and self-enforcing.For example, suppose a bank has decided to reap the benefits of smart contracts and created a decentralized system on the Ethereum blockchain to handle its accounting. Now, the bank wishes to issue a mortgage to a borrower. The parties agree to run their mortgage on the Ethereum network, thereby automating payments without the need to develop or license a costly proprietary system. The computer-coded terms would be stored not only by the parties mentioned, but also every other node on the blockchain. This ensures that the smart contract cannot be changed without the consent of the bank and the borrower. If the borrower does not have enough funds in his or her account, then the bank would be instantly notified and different terms could be enforced in the event of a default. And, once the borrower has paid back the mortgage, the network would update and automatically remove the debt obligation on the bank’s system. If properly programmed and linked with an available smart contract processing title documents, the final payment would automatically update the title of the home and remove the bank’s lien on the property.
Other examples abound. In the world of financial transactions, smart contracts can be programmed to execute various trades (e.g., stocks, bonds, Bitcoin) when certain conditions precedent are satisfied and without having to trust any party to perform the transactions. A supply chain blockchain can automatically track goods in real time, properly route them to the correct destinations, and remit payments to the appropriate parties along the way. An artist can track the use of his or her intellectual property in real time as well as manage those digital rights and receive payment without the long line of intermediaries that currently dominate the system (e.g., Apple’s 1/3 cut). A company can automatically track its shares, update its cap table, and administer shareholder voting. With smart contracts, these and many more processes that ordinarily require several layers of human oversight can be more easily managed, provide data in real time, reduce overhead and confusion, and create new opportunities.
However, utilizing a distributed network (public or private) requires not only retooling a business’s current environment, but also obtaining buy-in from all of the interested parties. Because smart contracts process binding transactions, a company’s counsel (in-house and/or external)should be involved with their development and deployment to ensure that the smart contracts reflect the human negations and do not expose the business to otherwise unforeseen legal consequences. Most critically, there must be meaningful cooperation among the parties that will use the system and the software developers who will help code them.
Building Blocks: Creating and Deploying Smart Contracts
In order to craft and deploy smart contracts that accurately reflect the parties’ understanding, that transform the way transactions are executed, maintained, administered, and enforced,and that reliability replace standard contracts (in whole or in part), lawyers, software developers, and the interested parties to the transaction must collaborate in a number of meaningful ways.
The traditional contract will also set forth what kind of platform the parties will run among themselves. Broadly speaking, the platform will be either a public blockchain, like Ethereum, or a private blockchain, like a Hyperledger project. The advantage of a public blockchain is that the platform is already built and trusted. However, it is more difficult to ensure privacy, efficient transactions times, and develop sophisticated tools on such a platform. The alternative, a private blockchain, requires more upfront investment and buy-in from the participants, as it must be customized. Either option will fundamentally do the same two things: form a universal consensus on the facts and execute actions based on that consensus. This first technical decision, as well as all those that flow from it, must anticipate the legal requirements of data storage, privacy, and the transactions to be performed on the blockchain. The parties’ legal teams are best positioned to aid in this decision.
Once the platform is built, the parties need to develop and deploy their smart contracts. Much like the creation of other customized digital applications, software developers write the code to perform specific functions and the users of the code (i.e., the various parties to the smart contract) interface with the application by providing correct inputs and access to the appropriate information. During this process, however, the developers need the support of legal specialists, who can accurately convey the legal requirements of the code as well as listen to, and work with, the developers when a straightforward method of coding for the legal parameters cannot be achieved.
To execute or go live with a smart contract, a party must “sign” the contract. Unlike in the case of traditional contracts, smart contract execution is not achieved through a handwritten or electronic signature. Rather, every party on the platform has a unique signing tool, its private key. By running its private key against a smart contract, the smart contract will execute the functions the party requires of it. This “signing” leaves an indelible imprint stating the time that the party executed the smart contract.
Finally, the terms of the smart contract are broadcast to the entire decentralized system, which automatically updates the shared ledger after reaching consensus that the transaction is valid. To ensure privacy, the terms can be “hashed,” a cryptographic process whereby the terms are given unique markers that cannot be reverse engineered.
Although smart contracts deployed on the blockchain are relatively new phenomena, they are already profoundly transforming the way we conduct business. From shipping to banking, logistics management to livestock, the legal profession to insurance, and the entertainment industry to the Internet of Things (IoT), smart contracts are becoming more widely adopted across a range of uses cases for businesses, individuals, and even IoT devices. Successful creation and deployment of these smart contracts requires smart collaboration among the various stake holders, their developers, and their attorneys.
Matt Savare is a partner and Kurt Watkins is an associate at Lowenstein Sandler LLP, where they practice intellectual property, technology, blockchain, and privacy law.
Audi aims to sell one million cars in China in 2023
BEIJING (Reuters) – German premium automaker Audi aims to sell 1 million vehicles in China in 2023, versus 726,000 vehicles in 2020, the brand’s China chief Werner Eichhorn said on Wednesday.
Audi, which is making cars in the world’s biggest auto market with FAW Group, will also add more products in China, Eichhorn said. Audi’s rivals include Daimler and BMW.
(Reporting by Yilei Sun and Brenda Goh; Editing by Himani Sarka
Netflix forecasts an end to borrowing binge, shares surge
By Lisa Richwine and Eva Mathews
(Reuters) – Netflix Inc said on Tuesday its global subscriber rolls crossed 200 million at the end of 2020 and projected it will no longer need to borrow billions of dollars to finance its broad slate of TV shows and movies.
Shares of Netflix rose nearly 13% in extended trading as the financial milestone validated the company’s strategy of going into debt to take on big Hollywood studios with a flood of its own programming in multiple languages.
The world’s largest streaming service had raised $15 billion through debt in less than a decade. On Tuesday, the company said it expected free cash flow to break even in 2021, adding in a letter to shareholders, “We believe we no longer have a need to raise external financing for our day-to-day operations.”
Netflix said it will explore returning excess cash to shareholders via share buybacks. It plans to maintain $10 billion to $15 billion in gross debt.
“This is in sharp contrast to Disney and many other new entrants into the streaming market who expect to lose money on streaming for the next few years,” said eMarketer analyst Eric Haggstrom.
From October to December, Netflix signed up 8.5 million new paying streaming customers as it debuted widely praised series “The Queen’s Gambit” and “Bridgerton,” a new season of “The Crown” and the George Clooney film “The Midnight Sky.”
The additions topped Wall Street estimates of 6.1 million, according to Refinitiv data, despite increased competition and a U.S. price increase. Fourth-quarter earnings per share of $1.19 missed analyst expectations of $1.39.
With the new customers, Netflix’s worldwide membership reached 203.7 million. The company that pioneered streaming in 2007 added more subscribers in 2020 than in any other year, boosted by viewers who stayed home to fight the coronavirus pandemic.
COMPETITION HEATS UP
Now, Netflix is working to add customers around the globe as big media companies amp up competition. Walt Disney Co in December unveiled a hefty slate of new programming for Disney+, while AT&T Inc’s Warner Bros scrapped the traditional Hollywood playbook by announcing it would send all 2021 movies straight to HBO Max alongside theaters.
Disney said in December it had already signed up 86.8 million subscribers to Disney+ in just over a year.
“It’s super-impressive what Disney’s done,” Netflix Co-Chief Executive Reed Hastings said in a post-earnings analyst interview. Disney’s success, he added, “gets us fired up about increasing our membership, increasing our content budget.”
Netflix said most of its growth last year – 83% of new customers – came from outside the United States and Canada. Forty-one percent joined from Europe, the Middle East and Africa.
For January through March, Netflix projected it would sign up 6 million more global subscribers, behind analyst expectations of roughly 8 million.
Revenue for the fourth quarter rose to $6.64 billion compared with $5.47 billion a year ago, edging past estimates of $6.63 billion.
Net income fell to $542.2 million, or $1.19 per share, from $587 million, or $1.30 per share, a year earlier.
Netflix shares jumped 12.5% to $564.32 in extended trading on Tuesday.
(Reporting by Eva Mathews in Bengaluru and Lisa Richwine in Los Angeles; Editing by Sriraj Kalluvila and Matthew Lewis)
MGM Resorts drops takeover plan for Ladbrokes-owner Entain
By Tanishaa Nadkar
(Reuters) – Casino operator MGM Resorts International on Tuesday ditched plans to buy Ladbrokes owner Entain after the British company rejected an $11 billion takeover approach this month, sending Entain’s shares down nearly 12%.
The United States is seen as the next big growth market for sports betting, spawning a series of transatlantic partnerships tapping in to European technology and expertise. These include Caesars Entertainment agreeing last September to buy William Hill in a 2.9 billion-pound deal.
MGM said it would not submit a revised proposal or make a firm offer for Entain, which had said the approach announced two weeks ago significantly undervalued its business.
Entain shares closed down 11.9% at around 12.44 pounds in London. MGM shares were up 2.5% at $30.54 in New York trading late on Tuesday afternoon.
“We look forward to continuing to work closely with MGM to drive further success in the United States through the BetMGM joint venture,” Entain said in a statement.
Online betting firms have benefited during the COVID-19 pandemic-led lockdowns, as customers took to playing from home when casinos and betting shops were off-limits.
MGM had previously said a merger with the British bookmaker would be compelling and believed a deal would help expand BetMGM, which the two have operated since 2018.
The proposal, on the basis of 0.6 MGM share for each Entain share, was also backed by billionaire Barry Diller’s IAC. It valued Entain shares at 13.83 pence each when it was first announced.
Complicating matters, Entain Chief Executive Officer Shay Segev decided to step down just seven months into the role and in the middle of negotiations with MGM to take a job with sports streaming service DAZN.
Segev’s departure, as well as limited engagement in talks shown by Entain and a difference in price expectations between the two sides, led MGM to decide to walk away from the deal, according to a person familiar with the matter.
Entain, previously known as GVC, has itself expanded rapidly through a series of acquisitions and owns the bwin, Coral and Eurobet brands, operating traditional British high street betting shops as well as offering online gambling.
“While we are genuinely surprised MGM didn’t up its consideration … we don’t think this changes MGM’s ability to secure equity value enhancing benefits from the attractively growing US sports betting and iGaming pie,” JP Morgan analysts said.
The brokerage said it would not rule out further discussions with Entain depending on how the company shareholders reacted, adding it would be tough for someone else to buy Entain given so much potential equity value coming from the 50/50 BetMGM joint venture.
(Reporting by Tanishaa Nadkar in Bengaluru; Additional reporting by Joshua Franklin in Miami; Editing by Keith Weir and Matthew Lewis)
Why You Should Take On Debt To Stop Dilution
By Blair Silverberg, CEO of Capital Imagine an exciting space dominated by two major companies, each growing and developing at...
Audi aims to sell one million cars in China in 2023
BEIJING (Reuters) – German premium automaker Audi aims to sell 1 million vehicles in China in 2023, versus 726,000 vehicles...
Netflix forecasts an end to borrowing binge, shares surge
By Lisa Richwine and Eva Mathews (Reuters) – Netflix Inc said on Tuesday its global subscriber rolls crossed 200 million...
MGM Resorts drops takeover plan for Ladbrokes-owner Entain
By Tanishaa Nadkar (Reuters) – Casino operator MGM Resorts International on Tuesday ditched plans to buy Ladbrokes owner Entain after...
Mike Ashley’s Frasers ups stake in Hugo Boss to over 15%
(Reuters) – Mike Ashley-led Frasers said on Tuesday it has increased its stake in German luxury fashion house Hugo Boss...
Sterling rises above $1.37 for first time since 2018; UK inflation rises
By Elizabeth Howcroft LONDON (Reuters) – A combination of heightened risk appetite in global markets and UK-specific optimism lifted the...
Euro sinks amid broader risk rally against dollar
By Ritvik Carvalho LONDON (Reuters) – The euro struggled to join a broader risk rally against the dollar on Wednesday...
Britain to publish new weekly consumer spending data
LONDON (Reuters) – Britain’s statistics office said it would publish new weekly consumer spending data from Thursday, based on credit...
Mercedes unveils electric compact SUV in bid to outdo Tesla
By Nick Carey (Reuters) – Daimler AG’s Mercedes-Benz on Wednesday unveiled the EQA, a new electric compact SUV as part...
England soccer star Rashford nets younger buyers for Burberry
By Sarah Young LONDON (Reuters) – Burberry stuck to its full-year goals on Wednesday after a media campaign fronted by...