Airline Pilots Fear Retribution Over Refusing to Fly in Middle East, Aviators' Group Says

Pilots Voice Fears of Retribution for Refusing Dangerous Middle East Flights

Pilot Safety Concerns Amid Middle East Conflict

By Allison Lampert and Abhijith Ganapavaram

Fears of Retaliation for Refusing Risky Assignments

MONTREAL/NEW DELHI, April 10 (Reuters) - Airline pilots who have safety concerns about flying in the Middle East during the Iran war have told a global aviators' union group they fear blowback ranging from lost pay to being fired if they refuse assignments, its president Ron Hay said. 

Pilots from Lebanon to India have voiced "widespread" concerns they could face sanctions if they do not fly in often unpredictable conditions where airspace can close with little notice due to missile or drone strikes, according to the head of the International Federation of Air Line Pilot' Associations.

"There is an underlying fear of retribution," Hay told Reuters in his first interview on the matter. 

Restoration of Flights Despite Ongoing Threats

His comments come as some Middle Eastern carriers continue to restore flights even as a two-week ceasefire announced on Tuesday faces challenges from continued attacks.

Job Security and Pay Concerns

Hay, a Delta Air Lines captain, said some of the pilots worried about being fired. For others, "they may not lose their job but they (managers) may say, 'Don't fly the trip and you don't get paid for it.'" 

He declined to name the airlines involved but said these were examples of how not to run a positive safety culture where pilots were encouraged to speak up.

“That’s been lacking in the Middle East region for quite some time and it’s just been exacerbated by this conflict,” Hay said.

Union Representation and Airline Safety Measures

IFALPA Membership in the Region

Montreal-based IFALPA has member associations in Bahrain, Egypt, Israel, Kuwait and Lebanon, according to its website. It does not list member associations at major Gulf carriers in the United Arab Emirates and Qatar, which are not unionized.

Carrier Safety Prioritization

Middle Eastern carriers have said they prioritize safety. Flights to and from the UAE and Qatar are operating through dedicated corridors set with regulators.

Pilot Reluctance to Speak Publicly

Reuters attempted to contact more than a dozen pilots based in the Gulf to discuss whether they were comfortable flying in the current environment, but all declined to speak even on condition of anonymity or did not respond to queries.

Regulatory and Organizational Responses

Continued Flight Operations Amid Restrictions

MIDDLE EAST CONCERNS

After the ceasefire was announced, the European Union Aviation Safety Agency extended its ban on European airlines operating in the airspace of several Gulf countries, including the UAE and Qatar, until April 24. But carriers based in Dubai and Doha are continuing to fly there, as are Indian airlines.

IFALPA's Call for Pilot Safety Authority

Concerns from aviators operating in the Middle East led IFALPA to publish a paper this week reminding airlines that pilots must be given a "non-negotiable" say on safety, Hay said.

"There is a deep concern within the region, which is part of the reason the paper was generated."

Mental Health Risks in Conflict Zones

A bulletin issued by the U.N.'s aviation agency on Thursday called mental health risks in conflict zones "safety critical."

"Personnel engaged in civil aviation operations within or near conflict zones can experience higher levels of stress, anxiety and fatigue - both on the ground and in the air," the bulletin said. 

Operational Challenges and Local Impacts

Lack of Guidance and Risk Assessment

Hay said pilots who are flying into the region have lamented a lack of guidance on risks, making it harder to plan if an airport is suddenly shut due to a drone attack. 

In late March, Indian member pilots of IFALPA called Air India's continued operation of flights to the impacted Gulf region a "grave concern." The pilot group urged the country's civil aviation regulator in a letter to suspend operations until a centralized "risk assessment is conducted."

Air India has engaged risk consultants who monitor whether it is safe to fly on a daily basis, a source familiar with the matter said. India's aviation regulator did not respond immediately to a request for comment.   

Personal Safety Beyond the Cockpit

Pilots have also been affected in other ways. Hay said he received a recent query from members in Beirut whose challenges did not end upon landing. 

“The roads between the airport and their house had been completely bombed," he said. "They didn’t even know how they could get home.”

(Reporting by Allison Lampert in Montreal and Abhijith Ganapavaram in New Delhi; Additional reporting by Julie Zhu in Hong Kong; Editing by Jamie Freed)