Trump Plan or Not, Israel Is Letting More Palestinians Leave Gaza

Israel Eases Gaza Border Control, More Palestinians Depart

By Nidal al-Mughrabi, Alexander Cornwell, Maayan Lubell

CAIRO/RAMALLAH/ISRAEL-GAZA BORDER (Reuters) -For more than a year, Israeli authorities prevented Ayed Ayoub from escaping Gaza's hunger and war with his family for an academic fellowship in France. He finally left last month, after Israel unexpectedly eased its tight control of the border.

Ayoub, his wife and their four children are among around 1,000 Palestinians who have left Gaza following Israel's relaxation of rules in recent months, bussed from the enclave to board flights to Europe and elsewhere, according to interviews with affected Gazans and foreign diplomats. 

"The situation in Gaza has become unbearable," said 57-year-old Ayoub, an engineer who earned his doctorate and masters degree at a French university after moving there in the early 2000s. His return was as part of a group of 115 Gazans accepted by France in April.

The new departures require a request to Israel by a foreign government and their numbers remain relatively small. 

Reuters could not establish why Israel was now letting more Palestinians leave Gaza, which comes amid international outcry over the humanitarian conditions there. However, the easing of restrictions parallels the Israeli government's stated goal of facilitating the resettlement of Gaza's population in other countries.

For Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, talk of mass resettlement of Palestinians from Gaza has helped shore up support with far-right allies who oppose a further truce with Hamas and want to re-establish Jewish settlements there.

Interior Minister Moshe Arbel has described the recent departure of Gazans to European countries as a bid to temporarily and voluntarily vacate the Gaza Strip to allow for its reconstruction, a process he said was inspired by Donald Trump. 

The Republican U.S. president has proposed developing the enclave as a coastal resort, free of Palestinians. 

"I thank President Trump for thinking of this important initiative," Arbel said on April 1, after supervising the departure of a flight taking Gazans to Germany. "Together, joining forces, we will turn this place into a paradise. With God's help, let us succeed."

His spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment. After the evacuation that Ayoub's family were part of, the French Foreign Ministry said France remained opposed to the forced displacement of people from Gaza. United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres has warned that the Trump idea could amount to ethnic cleansing. 

Despite the comments from Arbel, five Israeli officials told Reuters the easing of restrictions was not a direct response to Trump's Gaza proposal or part of any such plan. One of the Israeli officials said Israel was not trying to reduce Gaza's population but rather responding to mounting requests by countries seeking to help people reach a safe destination.  

For many Palestinians, the opportunity to move is fraught with echoes of historical dispossession of their lands. Ayoub and others among those who recently left told Reuters their departure was only temporary. However, nearly half of Gazans would now consider leaving, according to a recent Palestinian poll, after Israel's 19-month offensive has left much of the strip in ruins, with its population largely displaced and dependent on dwindling aid supplies.

Policies in place since Israel broke a fragile six-week ceasefire on March 2 further increased pressure on Gaza's population, even as U.S. and Arab mediators push for an end to the war.

Famine risks have worsened under Israel's two-month blockade of all aid deliveries in Gaza. It renewed a bombing campaign, killing 464 people last week, according to Gaza's Health Ministry. And it launched a new "extensive" land offensive on Sunday, two days after Trump concluded a tour of Gulf states. 

Israel also said on Sunday it would ease the blockade and allow in limited aid.

Netanyahu has hailed Trump's idea for Gaza but cites a major obstacle: "We have one problem - we need receiving states," he told a hawkish group of Gaza war veterans on Tuesday. Neighbours Jordan and Syria - which have large Palestinian refugee populations dating back decades - and Egypt are loathe to take in large numbers of Gazans.

For this story, Reuters spoke with five Gazans who have left recently, along with nine foreign diplomats and seven Israeli officials to establish details of the impact of the new rules around exits from Gaza.

The foreign diplomats said Israel began informing foreign governments late last year, before Trump took office and floated his proposal, that they would soon ease the restrictions. The diplomats asked to remain anonymous because they were not authorised to speak to the media.

The relaxed restrictions largely took effect at the start of the year. Israeli officials now take days instead of weeks or months to approve requests for Palestinians with foreign citizenship, their relatives, and recipients of foreign scholarships, the diplomats involved said. Among those now allowed to leave were Palestinians previously denied exit by Israel on security grounds, they added.

Israel's Prime Minister's office, Defence Ministry and its COGAT branch which coordinates with the Palestinians did not respond to Reuters queries about the scope or reason for the recent easing of restrictions. Hamas, which has urged Gazans not to take part in any relocation offers, said it was looking into reports of restrictions being eased. 

GAZA

The population of Gaza has already fallen by about 160,000 during the course of the war to around 2.1 million, according to the Palestinian statistics agency. More than 53,000 residents have been killed and the rest have left, including some allowed out for medical emergencies. Others have been able to leave through an expensive system involving Egyptian brokers.

Thousands of foreign nationals fled earlier in the war, but it became much harder to get permission once Israel took over the Rafah crossing with Egypt in May last year and enforced a near-total closure of Gaza's borders.

In late March, Israel's government established a new agency that would help Gazans who want to resettle in third countries. Reuters was unable to establish whether the department is functioning.

Reuters could not establish exactly how many people had been able to leave under the new criteria. Three diplomats estimated at least a thousand, while several said they could only be sure of their own citizens, citing numbers in the high hundreds.

Israeli authorities did not respond to a question about numbers.

Over a dozen, primarily European, countries have now been able to get people out from Gaza, with most exits occurring since March, all the diplomats said.

Gisha, an Israeli human rights group that advocates for freedom of movement for Palestinians, said Israel's easing of restrictions were "partial, inconsistent, and non-transparent," arguing that many more people should be allowed to leave.

"What may appear to be 'concessions' are, in fact, selective and limited responses to international pressure and legal action," Gisha spokesperson Shai Grundberg told Reuters.      

The organisation estimates thousands of Palestinians still in Gaza hold foreign citizenship, residency, student visas, or eligibility for entry into a third country through family reunification visas or similar programs.

'WE WILL COME BACK'

Only a fraction of Gazans meet the present Israeli criteria for being allowed out. For those who do, the choice is not easy.

Many fear leaving their land would result in another "Nakba" or catastrophe, when hundreds of thousands of Palestinians were dispossessed of their homes in the 1948 war between Arab states and the newly created state of Israel. Many of those hoping to return within weeks remained refugees.    

"We will come back to Gaza once the conditions allow, as soon as we can," said poet Dunia Al-Amal Ismail, a 53-year-old widow who made it out as part of the same group as Ayoub, with her 21-year-old daughter and 18-year-old son.

Ismail secured a place in the same French academic program that helps researchers, artists and their families get out of conflict zones.

Those leaving face a perilous journey through the enclave, which is scattered with unexploded rockets and shells. Palestinians are gathered by vehicles before dawn and driven to an Israeli-run border crossing, where they undergo Israel security checks before being processed by foreign diplomats, the people Reuters spoke to said.

Israel only allows those leaving to bring one small bag each. They travel in buses under Israeli military escort to the Jordan border, four diplomats said.

Aware of severe food scarcity, the diplomats said they bring sandwiches and drinks for those leaving Gaza.

One diplomat said a Palestinian man, eating a chicken sandwich, had commented that he had forgotten the taste of meat.

An academic among the group that recently arrived in France described meeting the diplomats in the desert.

"All of a sudden, a fridge appears from nowhere, and you see everything you have been deprived of for many months," he told Reuters. "I ate, but with pain in my chest for the people who we left behind."

Several of the Palestinians Reuters spoke to declined to be identified for fear of retribution from Hamas and other armed groups.

Travel documents present logistical challenges, several of the diplomats said. Some papers have been lost in the war, while others are needed for children born since it began. Some must have travel documents issued by the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah or Cairo, they said.                

From Jordan, they board flights to the countries that helped them leave, though there have been some flights from Israel, according to the diplomats, flight data and Israel's Interior Ministry.

For Ayoub, painful memories weigh heavily.

One of Ayoub's sisters, her husband and their son were killed in bombardments at the start of the war, which was triggered by the Hamas-led attack on southern Israeli communities on October 7, 2023, in which about 1,200 people were killed and 251 were taken as hostages to Gaza.

Ayoub's nephew, an architect, had also recently won a fellowship in France but never made it out. He died on Thursday from injuries he sustained in an airstrike. The French programme backing the fellowship issued a statement mourning his death.

Ayoub was conflicted about leaving: relieved to secure a better future for his children but at the same time distraught "because I left my sister and her children, and many people who are dear to me," he said, referring to another of his siblings.

"One moment I'm happy, and the next I remember what's happening in Gaza," Ayoub said.

(Writing by Maayan Lubell and Alexander Cornwell; Additional reporting by Mustafa Abu Ganeyeh, James Mackenzie, Nuha Sharaf and Emily Rose in Jerusalem, Padraic Halpin in Dublin, Stephanie Van Den Berg in Amsterdam; Joanna Plucińska and William James in London, Angelo Amante in Rome; Editing by Frank Jack Daniel)